Evidence Strength
Cases sorted by how convincing the evidence was in the court's own reasoning -- for decided cases only. This reflects the court's own conclusions, not our judgment of guilt or innocence.
Thin evidence
The court reached its verdict on limited, circumstantial, or contested evidence -- for example a single witness account, or evidence the defense seriously challenged.
50/50
The evidence was mixed -- meaningful points on both sides, with the court weighing competing accounts or interpretations before reaching its decision.
Overwhelming evidence
The court's verdict rested on strong, multiple, and largely uncontested evidence -- for example forensic proof, video footage, or a confession corroborated by other evidence.
